top of page

The Great Manicure Debate: Gel Nails vs Regular Polish Explored

The beauty industry is constantly innovating and introducing new products to choose from. One of the latest trends in gel manicures, which involves curing the polish under a nail lamp. Gel manicures are touted as lasting longer and having a high-shine finish. However, many still prefer the convenience and lower cost of traditional nail polish.

The Great Manicure Debate examines the pros and cons of gel nails versus regular polish from various angles. Factors like durability, damage risks, application time, removal difficulties, and cost-effectiveness are discussed. Both options have their trade-offs, and the best choice depends on individual priorities and preferences. The core question at the heart of the debate is: are the benefits of gel nails worth the higher price tag and potential downsides? In this article, we explore the subject, leveraging our professional expertise in both types of manicures.

Gel Nails and Regular Polish

A Closer Look at Gel Nails

Gel polish, sometimes just called gel, is a super long-lasting type of polish made with a special polymer. You apply it like regular polish but to make it dry, you put it under a UV or LED lamp. While it's a newer type of polish, gel has gotten popular for how durable and shiny it is.

Gel polish is pretty different from your basic polish. It has special ingredients that make it so it can't dry in air, it needs that Nail lamp light to cure. This means every extra coat needs the same treatment, making the application a bit trickier than regular polish.

Regular Polish Unveiled

Your average nail polish, also known as traditional polish, is made with color pigments dissolved in a solvent. As the solvent evaporates, it leaves behind a coating of color on your nails. The application is straightforward: shape your nails, apply a base coat, then the polish color, and finally a top coat. Let it dry in the air, and voila, you've got yourself a manicure.

Application Process: Gel Nails vs Regular Polish

The Steps for Gel Manis

Gel polish requires more work to apply. After shaping your nails and a base coat, you apply a layer of gel polish. This type of polish doesn't dry in air on its own. Instead, you need an LED light to cure it and make it hard while keeping the texture. Each extra coat needs the same treatment.

Applying Regular Nail Polish

In contrast, regular polish is easier to apply. You shape your nails, apply a base coat, then the color coat, and finally a top coat. Let it air dry naturally and your manicure is done. This simplicity and ease are why regular nail polish has been a staple in homes for so long.

Lifespan and Durability

Gel Polish Lasts Way Longer

One major perk of gel polish is its durability. A gel manicure can stay perfect for up to 3 weeks, way longer than regular polish. This is because the gel formula makes it more resistant to chipping and peeling. Also, gel polish soaks deeper into the nail plate which strengthens the bond. Properly cured gel polish forms a hard, cross-linked coating that's very difficult for water to penetrate.

Regular Polish Is Short Lived

On the flip side, a regular manicure often lasts about 5-7 days and is prone to chipping quickly as you go about your day. Regular nail polish is composed of volatile organic compounds that allow it to dry by evaporation. This makes it more permeable to water and damage over time. Regular polish may be better if you like switching up your nail color frequently or prefer a simpler removal process without acetone soak-off.

Evaluating the Aesthetics

Gel Nail Polish Have That High-End Shine

Gel polish is known for its salon-quality shine and gloss that lasts the entire time you have your manicure. The special curing process with light helps lock in that high-gloss finish. Gel polish comes in a wide range of trendy colors and designs to suit any style. Due to its thick formula, gel polish can hide imperfections in the nail bed better than regular polish.

The Aesthetic Quality of Regular Polish

While regular polish doesn't have the same long-lasting shine, it offers way more variety in colors, styles, textures, and finishes. You have traditional polishes, shimmer polishes, glitters, mattes, and more. This makes regular polish great for those who want options to match any outfit or mood.

Cost Implications

Gel Nails Tend to Cost a little More

While gel manicures provide long-lasting shine, they generally come with a higher price tag compared to regular polish manicures. The increased cost is due to the longer application time and higher cost of gel polish formulas. Most nail salons in Fredericton offer gel polish application as an add-on service for an extra fee, above the cost of a basic manicure.

The Financial Aspects of Regular Polish

Regular polish offers a more cost-effective option, both for the polish itself and the cost of a basic salon manicure. The simpler application process makes regular polish suitable if you're seeking an affordable way to keep your nails nicely maintained. Most salons include the cost of regular polishes in the price of a basic manicure, making it a budget-friendly option for those who like having well-maintained, polished nails.

Safe Removal of Gel Nails and Regular Polish

Proper Gel Polish Removal Requires Professionals

Gel polish must be removed by a professional nail technician who has the tools and experience to remove it safely. The strong bond gel forms with your natural nails making DIY removal risky. If not removed properly, gel polish can cause lifting, peeling and damage to your nails and cuticles. Nail technicians can file away any damage or lifted gel after removal to get your nails back to their original state.

Regular Polish Removal Is Easy Breezy

In contrast, regular polish comes off easily with regular nail polish remover. Wiping it away with a cotton pad makes switching colors or going bare minimal effort. You can remove regular polish at home with little risk of damage.

Overall Analysis: Regular Polish vs. Gel Nails

Traditional and gel nail polish each has pros and cons. Which you choose often depends on preferences, needs, and lifestyle.

Summary of Pros and Cons

Gel nails are known for their durability and high-gloss finish. They can last up to 3 weeks without chipping, making them a great choice for those seeking a long-lasting manicure. However, the application and removal processes are more complex and time-consuming.

On the other hand, regular polish is easier to apply and remove, making it a convenient choice for many. It's also more affordable and allows for more frequent color changes. However, regular polish may not last as long and is more prone to chipping compared to gel polish.

Who Gel Manis Work Best For

Gel nails work well for those who want that high-end salon shine and don't mind the extra application steps. They're great if you use your hands a lot and need a durable mani.

Regular Polish Is Best For...

Regular polish is ideal for those who like a simple, quick manicure process. It's good for people who want to switch up their colors often.

When Each Option Works Best

Gel nails are good for events or trips since they last longer. They're fitting if you have a busy life and can't maintain regular polish as often.

Regular polish works well when you want to change your colors frequently. It's also a more affordable option if you're on a budget.

Luxury Nail Salon in Fredericton Offers All Nail Services

Vibrant Nail Salon in Fredericton caters to all your pampering needs. We offer a range of mani + pedi services from basic polishes to gel and shellac nails. Whether you want a classic look or something bold, our experienced nail techs can create it. We keep up with the latest trends so you have lots of style options to choose from.

At our relaxing nail bar, it's not just about the nails - it's the whole experience. Our caring nail techs make you feel pampered as they work their magic on your hands and feet. So whether you're getting ready for an event, want to switch up your regular look, or desire some self-care, our nail studio has you covered. We deliver a top-notch service in a chic, comfortable environment so you can truly unwind as we beautify your nails.


Can gel manicures be done on natural nails?

Yes, gel nail polish can be applied directly to your natural nails. They do not require the addition of fake nails or extensions.

Do I need to go to a nail salon for a gel manicure?

While gel manicures can be done at home with the right equipment, it's often recommended to have them done at a nail salon, especially if you're new to the process. Professionals at a nail salon have the right training and tools to ensure the manicure is done correctly and safely.

Can gel nail polish damage your nails?

If not removed properly, gel nail polish can potentially damage your nails.

Can I apply gel polish to my nails at home?

Yes, with the right tools and products, you can apply gel polish at home. However, it's important to follow the correct procedures for application and removal to avoid damaging your nails.

How does a traditional manicure compare to a gel manicure?

A traditional manicure involves the application of regular nail polish that dries naturally in the air. While the application process is simpler, traditional manicures may not last as long as gel manicures. However, they are easier to remove and allow for more frequent color changes.

Can I switch from regular polish to gel polish?

Yes, you can switch from regular polish to gel polish. However, keep in mind that the application and removal processes for gel polish are more complex and time-consuming than for regular polish.

Is gel polish more expensive than regular polish?

Generally, gel polish is more expensive than regular polish. This is due to its longer-lasting formula and the need for special nail equipments for application and curing.

Is it easier to remove gel polish or regular polish?

Regular polish is easier to remove than gel polish. Regular polish can be removed with a simple nail polish remover, while gel polish requires soaking in acetone and gentle scraping.


bottom of page